Watch Jaguar's Cringeworthy I-Pace Versus Tesla Model X Comparison Video


This was never going to be an objective comparison.

The Jaguar I-Pace is the first serious threat to the Tesla Model X, so comparisons were inevitable. What we didn’t expect to see, however, was a comparison test between the two EVs organized by Jaguar—because that wouldn’t be biased at all. On the day , the British luxury automaker uploaded a video showing it conducting a drag race between its new EV and the Model X.

The two all-electric SUVs were put head-to-head at the Autodromo Hermanos Rodriguez ePrix circuit in Mexico City ahead of this weekend’s Formula E race. Behind the wheel of the I-Pace was Panasonic Jaguar Racing’s Mitch Evans, while the Model X was driven by former IndyCar champion Tony Kanaan.

You Might Also Like
16 Of The Greatest  Engines Ever Made
16 Of The Greatest Engines Ever Made
Cool Muscle Cars For Under $25,000
Cool Muscle Cars For Under $25,000

The objective was simple: which electric SUV can accelerate from 0-60 mph and brake to a stop in the shortest distance? It’s an unusual comparison in a number of ways. Firstly, both cars might be electric SUVs, but they’re in completely different classes. The Jaguar I-Pace is a small crossover, whereas the Tesla Model X is a much larger SUV. A comparison between a similarly-sized gasoline SUV would have perhaps been a more fitting test. The I-Pace is also lighter than its competitor, so it beats the Model X in that regard. In the first drag race, the I-Pace, which Jaguar claims has a 0-62 mph time of 4.5 seconds, was pitted against a Model X 75D, which does the same sprint in 4.7 seconds. Predictably, the Jaguar won.

Then the comparisons got interesting. Kanaan suggested using a more powerful P100D. Most enthusiasts know the P100D can accelerate from 0-62 mph in 2.9 seconds and would therefore destroy the I-Pace in a drag race. But what does Jaguar do? They bring out a Tesla 100D—sans P—in the hope viewers would be none the wiser. Once again, the Jaguar beat the Tesla SUV, making it look like the I-Pace is faster than Tesla’s range-topping Model X in a drag race. Hopefully we’ll see some more accurate independent comparisons soon. Until then, we're left with a lopsided comparison test and the cringeworthy scripted dialogue of two racing drivers.